We have been able to consider the question of Savonarola’s obedience and excommunication independently of whether he was or was not a prophet, for a very simple reason: because the issue of obedience and excommunication concerns, on one hand, the concrete determinations of authority, according to the science of law and the prudence of command, and on the other hand, the corresponding commitment of the subject, according to the same legal science and moral virtue of submission. The question of prophecy, however, belongs to the realm of charisms—miracles, the gift of tongues, interpretation of Scripture, stigmata, raptures, bilocation, etc.—which are granted by God not directly for the sanctification of the chosen individuals, but for the common good of the Church.
To simplify this complex and delicate historical matter, we will broadly distinguish a speculative aspect and a practical aspect of the issue, as they were concretely lived out by Savonarola. First, let us examine Savonarola’s Thomistic doctrine of prophecy. In his sermon of May 8, 1496, Savonarola made this striking declaration from the pulpit:
“The principal reason I have come here (to the pulpit) is that I have done so out of obedience. To whom? To the Signoria? Do not believe it. I am not obligated in this matter to obey them. Forgive me. Then have you come because of the persuasion of men? Not at all; do not believe that I allowed myself to be persuaded in this by anyone. Have you therefore come to obey your Superiors? No, no Prelate of mine has told me to do this. But know that I have come up here to obey Him who is the Prelate of prelates and the Pope of popes, and who makes me do things against my own nature.”
Some have believed they found in these words irrefutable proof of Savonarola’s open rebellion. But this is not the case.
Once the legal legitimacy and moral righteousness of Savonarola are established, the Savonarolian question then moves onto the charismatic plane.
“It is forbidden to preach for one who is not sent,” Savonarola says in his sermon of May 12, 1496, “but the law does not forbid prophesying.”
That is, the license to preach is an act of jurisdiction from the competent ecclesiastical authority, whereas prophesying is a free election of the Holy Spirit.
However, if one wishes to remain within the bounds of sanctity, the legal question is a conditioning prerequisite, for the Holy Spirit would not bestow a habitual prophetic charism upon a rebellious preacher. It is therefore necessary to further clarify the preexisting legal condition of Savonarola, to see how his prophetic flame burns clear, without smoke.
For years, Savonarola had been regularly authorized to preach by his legitimate superiors, and, as a Dominican, under the terms of the bull of Honorius III, which recognized the Order of St. Dominic as an exempt religious order, meaning directly dependent on the Holy See. This explains, among other things, why the Florentine Curia never played a role in the Savonarolian question.
Even on May 28, 1495, shortly before the drama began, the General of the Dominicans had appointed Savonarola as Vicar General of the Congregation of San Marco, with the powers of a Provincial, a congregation that had just been established by decree of the Holy See.
That same year, Savonarola wrote in his “Compendium of Revelations”:
“…it is publicly known that I am sent by my superiors, and I do not say that I am sent by God alone and not by them.”
He wrote likewise in his letter of September 29, 1495 (cf. Alexander VI and Savonarola, op. cit., p. 74). In his sermon of February 11, 1498, after summarizing his defense against the attacks of those tormented years, he stated:
“...I have justified everything that has been brought against me, and this is known through our writings and letters. I have all my papers in order...”
Until the first prohibition on preaching on September 8, 1495, Savonarola’s actions were clearly grounded in the missio canonica, meaning authorization from the ecclesiastical hierarchy. However, an illegitimate action by those in authority could not remove that same authorization or missio canonica, as has been demonstrated above.
Within this framework of legal legitimacy, what moved—and would increasingly move—Savonarola to continue his apostolic battle was the exceptional gravity of the circumstances and the certainty, in conscience, of his prophetic mission, which he finally felt compelled to declare publicly so that his actions would not be seen as fantasy or as the product of human intrigue.
The prophetic charism, in short, is in Savonarola the crowning of an entire personal edifice of virtue, upon which God breathes with the breath of His spirit of prophecy (cf. P. Garrigou-Lagrange, Principes fondamentaux de la mystique selon Saint Thomas d’Aquin, in Saint Thomas d’Aquin, Editions de la Vie Spirituelle, Saint Maximin, 1933, p. 105).
In the aforementioned sermon of May 8, Savonarola explains:
“St. Thomas says in the second part (of the Summa Theologica, q. 174, a. 6, editor’s note) that in every age, for great needs, prophets were sent by God to enlighten the people, and the people must believe them, for by believing them, they will be enlightened by God and led to a safe harbor.”
Savonarola evidently applied this concept to himself, returning to it repeatedly in his sermons (May 18 and August 15, 1496), in the Letter to a Friend, and in his two precious booklets, The Compendium of Revelations (1495-1496) and The Dialogue on Prophetic Truths (1498).
Savonarola never appeals to the charismatic gift of prophecy or to any supernatural inspiration to invalidate the canonical dispositions concerning him (prohibition of preaching, excommunication, order to go to Rome). These dispositions invalidate themselves by their intrinsic legal inconsistency or are superseded by other fundamental principles, as has been shown.
The illumination of God, which in every baptized person humbly subject to the authority of order and jurisdiction of the Hierarchy comes from the Father of all lights S. T. III, q. 8), serves Savonarola in understanding the objective situation and in recognizing, within the hierarchical framework, his private and public duties before the Divine King and the Most Holy Trinity (sermon of February 18, 1498).
In his final sermons, recounting the history of these events, Savonarola sums up the entire matter in a sculptural phrase, demonstrating that he had a clear grasp of the canonical and charismatic aspects, which, in the Catholic synthesis, are connected in a homogeneous manner.
“I tell you, and you know it, that I am visibly sent and that I belong to the Order of Preachers, and I can preach canonical aspect, editor’s note). And I tell you also, to be clear, that I am sent by God, and we must preach, and we must fight against the whole world” charismatic aspect, editor’s note) (sermon of March 17, 1498).
Regarding the nature of prophecy, it is unnecessary to dwell on it at length, since Savonarola’s doctrine is none other than that of St. Thomas Aquinas, explicitly referenced in the cited passages (cf. S. T. II-II, q. 172 and following). Let us simply note the following characteristic aspects.
Before Christ, the prophets accompanied the Hebrew people, contributing to the formation of the deposit of Divine Revelation in anticipation of the fullness of the Messiah. With Revelation completed in Christ up to St. John the Evangelist, prophets continue throughout the Church’s history to accompany the Christian people, using their charism to radiate the Gospel, unfolding its infinite potential, toward the mission of Christ’s Mystical Body, which will be crowned by the Lord’s return in the fullness of His glory. In both cases, though with distinctions, the generic concept given by St. Thomas of a prophet is realized: one sent by God “for the direction of human acts insofar as is expedient for the salvation of the elect” S. T., q. 174, a. 6; Savonarola, sermon of May 8, 1496 and Letter to a Friend).
From all of Savonarola’s sermons, it is clear that his prophecy mainly consists in showing how contingent and future events fit within the perspective of Sacred Scripture, especially those of the Old Testament prophets whose relevance to his own time and mission he underscores, such as Amos, Jeremiah, and Ezekiel. He does this on an ever-new and ever-broader plane of history, without ever compromising the definitive and untouchable deposit of Revelation. He maintains a homogeneous vision of the whole, both from the perspective of revealed truth and from that of theological, philosophical, and cultural doctrinal commentary (cf. sermons of February 19, 20, 23, 24, 26, 28, 1496).
We have been able to consider the question of Savonarola’s obedience and excommunication independently of whether he was or was not a prophet, for a very simple reason: because the issue of obedience and excommunication concerns, on one hand, the concrete determinations of authority, according to the science of law and the prudence of command, and on the other hand, the corresponding commitment of the subject, according to the same legal science and moral virtue of submission. The question of prophecy, however, belongs to the realm of charisms—miracles, the gift of tongues, interpretation of Scripture, stigmata, raptures, bilocation, etc.—which are granted by God not directly for the sanctification of the chosen individuals, but for the common good of the Church.
To simplify this complex and delicate historical matter, we will broadly distinguish a speculative aspect and a practical aspect of the issue, as they were concretely lived out by Savonarola. First, let us examine Savonarola’s Thomistic doctrine of prophecy. In his sermon of May 8, 1496, Savonarola made this striking declaration from the pulpit:
“The principal reason I have come here (to the pulpit) is that I have done so out of obedience. To whom? To the Signoria? Do not believe it. I am not obligated in this matter to obey them. Forgive me. Then have you come because of the persuasion of men? Not at all; do not believe that I allowed myself to be persuaded in this by anyone. Have you therefore come to obey your Superiors? No, no Prelate of mine has told me to do this. But know that I have come up here to obey Him who is the Prelate of prelates and the Pope of popes, and who makes me do things against my own nature.”
Some have believed they found in these words irrefutable proof of Savonarola’s open rebellion. But this is not the case.
Once the legal legitimacy and moral righteousness of Savonarola are established, the Savonarolian question then moves onto the charismatic plane.
“It is forbidden to preach for one who is not sent,” Savonarola says in his sermon of May 12, 1496, “but the law does not forbid prophesying.”
That is, the license to preach is an act of jurisdiction from the competent ecclesiastical authority, whereas prophesying is a free election of the Holy Spirit.
However, if one wishes to remain within the bounds of sanctity, the legal question is a conditioning prerequisite, for the Holy Spirit would not bestow a habitual prophetic charism upon a rebellious preacher. It is therefore necessary to further clarify the preexisting legal condition of Savonarola, to see how his prophetic flame burns clear, without smoke.
For years, Savonarola had been regularly authorized to preach by his legitimate superiors, and, as a Dominican, under the terms of the bull of Honorius III, which recognized the Order of St. Dominic as an exempt religious order, meaning directly dependent on the Holy See. This explains, among other things, why the Florentine Curia never played a role in the Savonarolian question.
Even on May 28, 1495, shortly before the drama began, the General of the Dominicans had appointed Savonarola as Vicar General of the Congregation of San Marco, with the powers of a Provincial, a congregation that had just been established by decree of the Holy See.
That same year, Savonarola wrote in his “Compendium of Revelations”:
“…it is publicly known that I am sent by my superiors, and I do not say that I am sent by God alone and not by them.”
He wrote likewise in his letter of September 29, 1495 (cf. Alexander VI and Savonarola, op. cit., p. 74). In his sermon of February 11, 1498, after summarizing his defense against the attacks of those tormented years, he stated:
“...I have justified everything that has been brought against me, and this is known through our writings and letters. I have all my papers in order...”
Until the first prohibition on preaching on September 8, 1495, Savonarola’s actions were clearly grounded in the missio canonica, meaning authorization from the ecclesiastical hierarchy. However, an illegitimate action by those in authority could not remove that same authorization or missio canonica, as has been demonstrated above.
Within this framework of legal legitimacy, what moved—and would increasingly move—Savonarola to continue his apostolic battle was the exceptional gravity of the circumstances and the certainty, in conscience, of his prophetic mission, which he finally felt compelled to declare publicly so that his actions would not be seen as fantasy or as the product of human intrigue.
The prophetic charism, in short, is in Savonarola the crowning of an entire personal edifice of virtue, upon which God breathes with the breath of His spirit of prophecy (cf. P. Garrigou-Lagrange, Principes fondamentaux de la mystique selon Saint Thomas d’Aquin, in Saint Thomas d’Aquin, Editions de la Vie Spirituelle, Saint Maximin, 1933, p. 105).
In the aforementioned sermon of May 8, Savonarola explains:
“St. Thomas says in the second part (of the Summa Theologica, q. 174, a. 6, editor’s note) that in every age, for great needs, prophets were sent by God to enlighten the people, and the people must believe them, for by believing them, they will be enlightened by God and led to a safe harbor.”
Savonarola evidently applied this concept to himself, returning to it repeatedly in his sermons (May 18 and August 15, 1496), in the Letter to a Friend, and in his two precious booklets, The Compendium of Revelations (1495-1496) and The Dialogue on Prophetic Truths (1498).
Savonarola never appeals to the charismatic gift of prophecy or to any supernatural inspiration to invalidate the canonical dispositions concerning him (prohibition of preaching, excommunication, order to go to Rome). These dispositions invalidate themselves by their intrinsic legal inconsistency or are superseded by other fundamental principles, as has been shown.
The illumination of God, which in every baptized person humbly subject to the authority of order and jurisdiction of the Hierarchy comes from the Father of all lights S. T. III, q. 8), serves Savonarola in understanding the objective situation and in recognizing, within the hierarchical framework, his private and public duties before the Divine King and the Most Holy Trinity (sermon of February 18, 1498).
In his final sermons, recounting the history of these events, Savonarola sums up the entire matter in a sculptural phrase, demonstrating that he had a clear grasp of the canonical and charismatic aspects, which, in the Catholic synthesis, are connected in a homogeneous manner.
“I tell you, and you know it, that I am visibly sent and that I belong to the Order of Preachers, and I can preach canonical aspect, editor’s note). And I tell you also, to be clear, that I am sent by God, and we must preach, and we must fight against the whole world” charismatic aspect, editor’s note) (sermon of March 17, 1498).
Regarding the nature of prophecy, it is unnecessary to dwell on it at length, since Savonarola’s doctrine is none other than that of St. Thomas Aquinas, explicitly referenced in the cited passages (cf. S. T. II-II, q. 172 and following). Let us simply note the following characteristic aspects.
Before Christ, the prophets accompanied the Hebrew people, contributing to the formation of the deposit of Divine Revelation in anticipation of the fullness of the Messiah. With Revelation completed in Christ up to St. John the Evangelist, prophets continue throughout the Church’s history to accompany the Christian people, using their charism to radiate the Gospel, unfolding its infinite potential, toward the mission of Christ’s Mystical Body, which will be crowned by the Lord’s return in the fullness of His glory. In both cases, though with distinctions, the generic concept given by St. Thomas of a prophet is realized: one sent by God “for the direction of human acts insofar as is expedient for the salvation of the elect” S. T., q. 174, a. 6; Savonarola, sermon of May 8, 1496 and Letter to a Friend).
From all of Savonarola’s sermons, it is clear that his prophecy mainly consists in showing how contingent and future events fit within the perspective of Sacred Scripture, especially those of the Old Testament prophets whose relevance to his own time and mission he underscores, such as Amos, Jeremiah, and Ezekiel. He does this on an ever-new and ever-broader plane of history, without ever compromising the definitive and untouchable deposit of Revelation. He maintains a homogeneous vision of the whole, both from the perspective of revealed truth and from that of theological, philosophical, and cultural doctrinal commentary (cf. sermons of February 19, 20, 23, 24, 26, 28, 1496).
We have been able to consider the question of Savonarola’s obedience and excommunication independently of whether he was or was not a prophet, for a very simple reason: because the issue of obedience and excommunication concerns, on one hand, the concrete determinations of authority, according to the science of law and the prudence of command, and on the other hand, the corresponding commitment of the subject, according to the same legal science and moral virtue of submission. The question of prophecy, however, belongs to the realm of charisms—miracles, the gift of tongues, interpretation of Scripture, stigmata, raptures, bilocation, etc.—which are granted by God not directly for the sanctification of the chosen individuals, but for the common good of the Church.
To simplify this complex and delicate historical matter, we will broadly distinguish a speculative aspect and a practical aspect of the issue, as they were concretely lived out by Savonarola. First, let us examine Savonarola’s Thomistic doctrine of prophecy. In his sermon of May 8, 1496, Savonarola made this striking declaration from the pulpit:
“The principal reason I have come here (to the pulpit) is that I have done so out of obedience. To whom? To the Signoria? Do not believe it. I am not obligated in this matter to obey them. Forgive me. Then have you come because of the persuasion of men? Not at all; do not believe that I allowed myself to be persuaded in this by anyone. Have you therefore come to obey your Superiors? No, no Prelate of mine has told me to do this. But know that I have come up here to obey Him who is the Prelate of prelates and the Pope of popes, and who makes me do things against my own nature.”
Some have believed they found in these words irrefutable proof of Savonarola’s open rebellion. But this is not the case.
Once the legal legitimacy and moral righteousness of Savonarola are established, the Savonarolian question then moves onto the charismatic plane.
“It is forbidden to preach for one who is not sent,” Savonarola says in his sermon of May 12, 1496, “but the law does not forbid prophesying.”
That is, the license to preach is an act of jurisdiction from the competent ecclesiastical authority, whereas prophesying is a free election of the Holy Spirit.
However, if one wishes to remain within the bounds of sanctity, the legal question is a conditioning prerequisite, for the Holy Spirit would not bestow a habitual prophetic charism upon a rebellious preacher. It is therefore necessary to further clarify the preexisting legal condition of Savonarola, to see how his prophetic flame burns clear, without smoke.
For years, Savonarola had been regularly authorized to preach by his legitimate superiors, and, as a Dominican, under the terms of the bull of Honorius III, which recognized the Order of St. Dominic as an exempt religious order, meaning directly dependent on the Holy See. This explains, among other things, why the Florentine Curia never played a role in the Savonarolian question.
Even on May 28, 1495, shortly before the drama began, the General of the Dominicans had appointed Savonarola as Vicar General of the Congregation of San Marco, with the powers of a Provincial, a congregation that had just been established by decree of the Holy See.
That same year, Savonarola wrote in his “Compendium of Revelations”:
“…it is publicly known that I am sent by my superiors, and I do not say that I am sent by God alone and not by them.”
He wrote likewise in his letter of September 29, 1495 (cf. Alexander VI and Savonarola, op. cit., p. 74). In his sermon of February 11, 1498, after summarizing his defense against the attacks of those tormented years, he stated:
“...I have justified everything that has been brought against me, and this is known through our writings and letters. I have all my papers in order...”
Until the first prohibition on preaching on September 8, 1495, Savonarola’s actions were clearly grounded in the missio canonica, meaning authorization from the ecclesiastical hierarchy. However, an illegitimate action by those in authority could not remove that same authorization or missio canonica, as has been demonstrated above.
Within this framework of legal legitimacy, what moved—and would increasingly move—Savonarola to continue his apostolic battle was the exceptional gravity of the circumstances and the certainty, in conscience, of his prophetic mission, which he finally felt compelled to declare publicly so that his actions would not be seen as fantasy or as the product of human intrigue.
The prophetic charism, in short, is in Savonarola the crowning of an entire personal edifice of virtue, upon which God breathes with the breath of His spirit of prophecy (cf. P. Garrigou-Lagrange, Principes fondamentaux de la mystique selon Saint Thomas d’Aquin, in Saint Thomas d’Aquin, Editions de la Vie Spirituelle, Saint Maximin, 1933, p. 105).
In the aforementioned sermon of May 8, Savonarola explains:
“St. Thomas says in the second part (of the Summa Theologica, q. 174, a. 6, editor’s note) that in every age, for great needs, prophets were sent by God to enlighten the people, and the people must believe them, for by believing them, they will be enlightened by God and led to a safe harbor.”
Savonarola evidently applied this concept to himself, returning to it repeatedly in his sermons (May 18 and August 15, 1496), in the Letter to a Friend, and in his two precious booklets, The Compendium of Revelations (1495-1496) and The Dialogue on Prophetic Truths (1498).
Savonarola never appeals to the charismatic gift of prophecy or to any supernatural inspiration to invalidate the canonical dispositions concerning him (prohibition of preaching, excommunication, order to go to Rome). These dispositions invalidate themselves by their intrinsic legal inconsistency or are superseded by other fundamental principles, as has been shown.
The illumination of God, which in every baptized person humbly subject to the authority of order and jurisdiction of the Hierarchy comes from the Father of all lights S. T. III, q. 8), serves Savonarola in understanding the objective situation and in recognizing, within the hierarchical framework, his private and public duties before the Divine King and the Most Holy Trinity (sermon of February 18, 1498).
In his final sermons, recounting the history of these events, Savonarola sums up the entire matter in a sculptural phrase, demonstrating that he had a clear grasp of the canonical and charismatic aspects, which, in the Catholic synthesis, are connected in a homogeneous manner.
“I tell you, and you know it, that I am visibly sent and that I belong to the Order of Preachers, and I can preach canonical aspect, editor’s note). And I tell you also, to be clear, that I am sent by God, and we must preach, and we must fight against the whole world” charismatic aspect, editor’s note) (sermon of March 17, 1498).
Regarding the nature of prophecy, it is unnecessary to dwell on it at length, since Savonarola’s doctrine is none other than that of St. Thomas Aquinas, explicitly referenced in the cited passages (cf. S. T. II-II, q. 172 and following). Let us simply note the following characteristic aspects.
Before Christ, the prophets accompanied the Hebrew people, contributing to the formation of the deposit of Divine Revelation in anticipation of the fullness of the Messiah. With Revelation completed in Christ up to St. John the Evangelist, prophets continue throughout the Church’s history to accompany the Christian people, using their charism to radiate the Gospel, unfolding its infinite potential, toward the mission of Christ’s Mystical Body, which will be crowned by the Lord’s return in the fullness of His glory. In both cases, though with distinctions, the generic concept given by St. Thomas of a prophet is realized: one sent by God “for the direction of human acts insofar as is expedient for the salvation of the elect” S. T., q. 174, a. 6; Savonarola, sermon of May 8, 1496 and Letter to a Friend).
From all of Savonarola’s sermons, it is clear that his prophecy mainly consists in showing how contingent and future events fit within the perspective of Sacred Scripture, especially those of the Old Testament prophets whose relevance to his own time and mission he underscores, such as Amos, Jeremiah, and Ezekiel. He does this on an ever-new and ever-broader plane of history, without ever compromising the definitive and untouchable deposit of Revelation. He maintains a homogeneous vision of the whole, both from the perspective of revealed truth and from that of theological, philosophical, and cultural doctrinal commentary (cf. sermons of February 19, 20, 23, 24, 26, 28, 1496).
Tav. 2.19.1, The Prophecy Question. Manifesto, Studio Fratesco, 2022. Progetto grafico: Alexander Norton.
Dialogo sul Savonarola, Bologna, Edizioni Studio Domenicano, 1985
